Nov 20 2009

Why HP and Lawyers Don’t Mix

The simple answer is: lawyers actually have work to do. Often, that is why they buy computers.  Therefore, lawyers who want to get work done must buy computers that work.  The logic is simple.    But of course, even the best products break now and again.  That’s why there are repair people, and in the world of computers, tech service workers, a special breed of customer service employees, who are supposed to help resolve your problem.  It is often at this juncture, when the computer customer has a technical issue, that business relationships are cemented, or forever broken.  Unfortunately, Hewlett Packard has not learned this lesson just yet, based on my experience (and that of many others, if you search online).

My HP Mini netbook began not working properly about 6 weeks ago. Among other things, the memory filled up to the point that it slowed internet access, and computer function in general, despite my frequent deleting of unneeded programs and files. Then, I lost the intenet connection entirely.  Among the many clueless folks in India or Pakistan that I spoke with, and barely understood, one instructed me to purchase a media pocket drive to transfer excess files to.  Spent the money, set it up, and it failed to address the problem. The next tech person told me the first one had been wrong, and I spent another 3-4 hours on the phone without solving the problem.  By this point, I had been on the phone for about 10 hours, spread out over a few days, and spent $100.00 for an HP product I never needed, and still had a broken computer.
After more wasted time and frustration, yet another tech person told me that I needed to delete everything from my computer, and re-install everything, with the 3 discs that they’d be sending me in the mail. I waited a few more days, got the discs, did what was suggested, and the computer remained just as broken.
Several hours of frustration on the phone with these incompetents later, I was told I’d have to send the computer to their TX repair facility.  Several days later, I received the FedEx box in which to place it. It went to TX, and came back with a slip saying the hard drive had been replaced.  Can you guess what happened when I tried to use it? That’s right. Still broken.
By this point, I had been without the ability to use the computer I’d purchased for a good 5 weeks, and things were not looking very promising with HP’s “help.”  I asked for either my money back, or a new computer, as I had already wasted untold days of frustration attempting, in good faith, to have my computer–still under warranty–fixed.
Unfortunately, HP’s policy is that my computer has to have been to TX for repair 3 times before they will take such a step.  (Getting the picture here?  Not exactly bending over backwards for the customer.)
As I sit here typing, I am waiting for the second FedEx box to take my computer back to TX, and having fantasies about renting a steamroller and running over my computer, many times, instead, since that will probably be equally useful in terms of the repair process.
Yesterday, after getting nowhere with the “Quality Case Manager” I’d been assigned to, I asked for the phone number to the president of the company, and called it.  When I reached the Executive Suite, and asked to speak with the President, I was literally told (but very sweetly) “that’s not an option.”
And so it goes on.  I will likely abandon any further attempts to fix this product, because it is just not worth the time and effort any longer.

And the bottom line is, I need a computer that works, and a company that will stand behind it when it doesn’t.  HP does not fit the bill.  You have fair warning.

  • Share/Bookmark
TAGS:

5 Comments on this post

Trackbacks

  1. Eric T. said:

    Get a Mac. And get the AppleCare extended warranty.

    If you ever have a problem, they will be there for you.

    November 20th, 2009 at 12:20 pm
  2. Gerry Oginski said:

    Andy- you need to switch to a Mac.
    Then you need to come to MILOfest (Macs in Law Offices) seminar.
    Then you need to follow the Mac Lawyer (Ben Stevens) for all things legal and Mac-related.

    You will be liberated and fully functional.

    Gerry

    November 20th, 2009 at 10:35 pm
  3. Andrew Barovick said:

    Gerry and Eric,
    Thank you. I am beginning to see some shopping in my future.
    Andy

    November 21st, 2009 at 4:56 am
  4. NiteStar said:

    HP’s tech support department is just short of an abomination. Over the past few years the level of competence and ability to resolve customer issues has steeply declined. Every interaction I’ve had with HP’s tech support department (at various levels) over the past few years–both for my own purposes and on behalf of clients–has been, at best, a failure and waste of time and, at worst, a complete disaster. See my own blog post that describes some of the horrors I’ve experience with HP’s tech support department: http://bit.ly/5IftcY

    November 28th, 2009 at 2:14 pm
  5. David Silverman said:

    Had a similar problem with an HP notebook during first year of law school.

    I got to the third round of sending, adn re-sending mine to Texas. Sent many letters and emails (one even tot he President of HP); and, I was finally connected with a tech support person… from Canada.

    This time, instead of my sending back the notebook for the third time, he sent me a hard-drive, and walked me through the repair.

    This was four years ago, the notebook worked for a few months after that, and it broke again. At that point, the warranty lapsed, and they wouldn’t take it back.

    Finally, I simply cracked-open the warranty-less paperweight, discovered the fan had been fried, and replaced it. That fixed the problem.

    In the end, for me I felt like I was on the tip of an iceberg of a products case where the central component was a design defect (putting an AMD processor in a box with a fan that couldn’t cool it enough, and thereby costing the consumers countless dollars in time and repair costs).

    Simply put, HP doesn’t design laptops very well, and they could never seem to get the hang of cooling a box down enough to make sure a hard-drive doesn’t melt.

    And I went to school to learn the law, not computers.

    February 5th, 2010 at 8:36 am

LEAVE A COMMENT

Subscribe Form

Subscribe to Blog